Sunday, February 8, 2015

Greek Banks and ELA

The noose is tightening on Greece. Until last Thursday, private Greek banks that were having liquidity problems were allowed to get emergency financing from the European Central Bank by providing collateral for new loans.

The thing is, the collateral the ECB was willing to accept was the government bonds of the Greek government.

On last Thursday, the ECB announced that it would no longer accept this collateral.

This is a rather bald statement that they are no longer sure, that if the banks expect to make interest payments based on debt service paid by the Greek government, that this business plan will work.

For now, the ECB has switched to a more serious form of short-term relief for Greek banks called ELA, along with a higher interest rate. ELA gets reviewed every two weeks, and if it gets stopped, it’s hard to see the Greek financial system avoiding collapse.

This is not an improvement.

Monday, February 2, 2015

4th Quarter GDP Report

The advance announcement of real GDP for 2014 IV came out on Friday morning. The rate of growth of real GDP was estimated at an annualized rate of 2.6% for the quarter.

This is below the historical average of 3.0 to 3.5% per year, although it's little bit better than we've been averaging since the last trough in 2009.

The weak performance during this recovery is shown here:

One thing you should keep in mind, especially in Utah where everything associated with Obama typically gets the negative treatment, is that we've had 3 expansions in a row that started out weakly. In fact, if you look closely at the right hand side of the chart, you can see just the beginnings of the high growth that Clinton is remembered for, and which didn't start until about 5 years after he took office.

One of the notable things about this somewhat weak growth report is that the number was dragged down by net exports, as shown in the bottom center panel of this chart:

Recall that exports are added into GDP but imports are subtracted out.

This is perverse. Here's why.

What do you want? Goods or work? This is a no-brainer: you want the goods, and you don't want to work to get them.

But what it means for your imports to exceed your exports is that you're getting more goods for less work. That's what you want, right? Except that when we count GDP, we do the opposite.

Why do we do that? It goes back to the reasons we started measuring GDP in the first place: who was going to win a war because their economy is bigger. If you want that, you want people working and exporting, rather than importing and enjoying their stuff. In short, GDP measures what the government wants its subjects to do, not what they'd actually like.

Now, this position does require an overhaul of how we think about GDP and GDP growth. That's beyond the scope of this post. But it does mean that every time you see a GDP growth rate, you should look and see if it's boosted by exports (which is what they want but not what you want) or brought down by imports (which is what you want but not what they want).

So what does it mean that imports brought down the growth rate in the fourth quarter? It means that Americans were feeling good about the economic situation, and buying more of everything ... no matter where it was made. I don't know about you, but I feel good when I walk out of the store with more stuff ... no matter where it was made.

Read the whole thing, entitled "U.S. Economy Hits Speed Bumps" in the January 31 issue of The Wall Street Journal.

Unusual New Croatian Policy

I'm not sure what to make of this at all ... and it really isn't on any macroeconomists radar screen just yet.

Anyway, Croatia put in place a policy today by which the government is cancelling the debts of a small chunk of the population.

This may or may not be related to the appreciation of the Swiss franc, in which many Croatian mortgages are denominated.

Interestingly, part of the reason for this policy change is that Croatia, as a relatively new country, has no bankruptcy law whatsoever. So there's no way for anyone to get out from under their debt burden, whether they have a good reason or not.

There are lots of links to this on the internet, but they all say pretty much the same thing. Here's one.

Sunday, February 1, 2015

Uh-Oh

The thing you should always worry about in democracy is that you’re voting for a package deal: if you like the person/party and vote for them, you get all their positions … not just the ones you like.

And what if those positions are bizarrely dumb? What does that say about the rest of the package?

So, in Greece, Syriza … within a week of winning the election … has put limiting all-inclusive vacation resorts on its agenda of things to fix.

You can’t make this stuff up.

When a new Greek activist government — under pressure to look like it’s doing something — declares that they believe all-inclusive resorts are bad because tourists stay on property instead of benefiting the local town economies nearby but promise they’re only talking theoretically and you should trust them that they aren’t going to do anything about it… you should trust them as much as you do that they’ll repay all of their bonds in full.

…

Tourism represents about a fifth of GDP. All-inclusive package tours are a key segment of the European market, especially for tourists coming from the UK and Germany.

Since tourism is important to the economy, and the economy is doing badly, it must be tourism’s fault.

FWIW: That makes the tourism industries size in Greece comparable proportional to the largest industry in the U.S. That would be FREI: finance, real estate, and insurance. Except that the latter are difficult, and people get paid a lot to do them because they’re valuable.

Via Marginal Revolution.

Thursday, January 29, 2015

Amputation?

Attitudes in the EU are hardening towards Greece. Here’s the problem:

Greece already enjoys the longest debt maturities and among the lowest interest costs as a proportion of gross domestic product of any eurozone government, thanks to past bailouts. Some further easing of repayment terms is possible, but governments aren’t prepared to be generous to Greek taxpayers …

The thing is, the EU has been just as hard (if not harder) on other faltering members. And some of those members are seeing success from their austerity plans. In particular, Spain (the 4th largest economy in the EU) seems to have turned a corner.

… It is Spain rather than Germany that may prove Mr. Tsipras’s most implacable opponent. Madrid is clear that any deal with the Greek leader must be based on reform commitments at least as tough as those demanded of former Prime Minister Antonis Samaras. Anything less would represent a win for Mr. Tsipras and fuel support for Spain’s own new radical leftist party, Podemos.

The Spanish government believes that the turnaround in its own economy—growth is expected to reach close to 3% next year and unemployment fell by 400,000 in 2014—is proof that a robust pro-market reform program is the only way to exit the crisis. Madrid believes that it would be in Spain’s and the eurozone’s best interests to allow Greece to crash out of the eurozone …

Would the EU amputate a toxic Greek limb to keep its main body well? It seems like we may find out.

Read about it in “Why the Eurozone May Need to Sacrifice Greece to Save Spain” in the January 28 issue of The Wall Street Journal.

Syriza Wasn’t Bluffing

Syriza is the party that just won power in Greece.

Often in democratic elections, a party will make claims that are somewhat outlandish … and then back off of them once it wins the election.*

Syriza has only taken a few days to do just the opposite, rattling markets.

Within hours of taking office, government officials said they would stop the planned sale of the state’s majority stake in Greece’s largest port and dominant utility. They also pledged to rehire thousands of public-sector workers and reopen the country’s state broadcaster, which had been shut down by the previous government.

The moves scuttled the expectations of some European officials that Greece’s new leadership would retreat from its radical campaign platform after attaining power. Greek stocks plummeted more than 9%, with the country’s four main banks falling more than 25%. The yield on two-year debt rose by 2.63 percentage points—an enormous move by bond-market standards—to 16.5% as Greek bond prices tumbled.

What they are worried about in the EU is contagion, and a flight to quality. There’s already small signs of that:

Elsewhere in Europe, bond prices in Italy, Spain and Portugal also edged lower, giving up some of their gains since the European Central Bank announced a major bond-buying program last week. Meanwhile, German 10-year government bonds—seen as a haven in times of debt market turbulence—rose, driving the yield to 0.35%, close to a record low.

Read the whole thing, entitled “Greece’s New Leaders Act Swiftly to Reverse Austerity” in the January 28 issue of The Wall Street Journal.

* My name for this comes from a description some pundit made 20 years or so ago about why Bill Clinton was able to combine political and economic success: “he doesn’t believe his own BS”.

A Form of Inequality that Perhaps We Should be Concerned About

Inequality has been a hot topic the last few years, motivated in part by the after effects of the Great Recession.

Many economists don’t take this too seriously (and I’m among them). With more experience with the data, it’s harder for us to see that inequality has actually gotten worse, or to judge whether or not that’s a bad thing.

However, one aspect of inequality that I think is well-supported (although I’m not sure it’s a bad thing) is that over the last 30 years or so, we’ve increasingly moved towards an economy in which stars and superstars get paid more than they used to. Consider this chart:

5-01-29 Inequality from The WSJI think this is fairly accurate (and the source is 2 macroeconomists, unlike a lot of graphics you see in legacy media publications, or political discussions).

I have a lot of trouble with the common claim by progressives that the median household has seen no improvement in real income in 30-40 years. I think that’s ridiculous.

But I do think that the gains at the top have been larger, and this graphic supports that.

I’m agnostic about whether this is good or a bad thing though. I simply know of no concrete evidence that a pattern like this is harmful. So for me, it’s just a fact that I feel you need to be aware of.

Now, one argument that I do think you need to have command of, is that a problem in interpreting a chart like this, is that it’s unlikely that the top 5% are the same people from year to year. We do know that there is some churn in the top 5%, and that weakens any case that inequality is a serious issue.

I drew this chart from the article entitled “How a Two-Tier Economy Is Reshaping the U.S. Marketplace” in the January 28 issue of The Wall Street Journal.