Thursday, January 21, 2016

Global Poverty

This “heat map” gives some sense of global poverty, by shading the proportions of the population living on $700 per year or less.

16-01-20 WSJ Global Poverty Map

The panel at the top left shows the really important piece of information: global poverty is down, over the last 25 years, by the most substantial amount in history. Anyone who tells you that things are getting worse on the planet is simply not telling you the truth.

The panel at the bottom left shows that most of the improvements have come in Asia. There’s still more poor people there, but a small proportion than there used to be.

The shading on the map shows the remaining problem arras. Not surprisingly, this is mostly in sub-Saharan Africa. Having said that, there are brighter spots dotted all over Africa. Maps like this used to be fairly solid all across that region.

This accompanied an article entitled “Slow Growth Clouds Fight Against Poverty” that appeared in the January 20 issue of The Wall Street Journal.

The Economy Is Underperforming Relative to Forecasts

This graphic shows the U.S. economy underperforming over the last several years.

16-01-20 WSJ Growth Forecasts

These graphics are getting more common, and can be hard to read.

The actual performance of the economy is the gray steps in the middle.

The colored bands are the forecasts made by a bunch of different forecasters. The color shows the year when they were made. The band go as far to the right as those forecasters predicted out into the future.

What we see is that:

  • In 2011, the gray bands forecast growth to be higher than it was in 2012 and 2013.
  • In 2012, the blue bands shows forecasts that are less optimistic than the previous year, and which still generally are too high for 2013-2015.
  • In 2013, the yellow bands show even more pessimistic forecasts, that are still to high. And so on for 2014 and maybe 2015.

There’s a couple of ways to look at this.

One is that the economy is underperforming. If that’s the case, the evidence we develop in class (as Case 5 in March) will show that this is because we continue to be hit by negative shocks. One negative shock after another is hard to reconcile with anything other than poor policy choices.

A second way is to view the forecasters as being systematically wrong. I’ll assert that we should dismiss this: individuals forecasters can be wrong, but groups of forecasters tend to do pretty well, so I’m incredulous that a bunch of them has been too high year after year.

A third way, and one which you need to be aware but which I am not encouraging you to put at the top of your list, is that the economy is fine but what we’re measuring is missing more stuff than it used to. Please go check out the post “What’s Wrong with America Right Now? Is It the Economy, or Is It Us?”, and pay particular attention to the Thanksgiving allegory given towards the end.

A Neat Graphic for Global Perspective

This was in a special section called “Outlook” of The Wall Street Journal on January 20. At one level, we are concerned with understanding the gross size of different economies. But at another, we’re concerned about proportions of the global economy. That’s what this one is all about.

image

The color scheme is common through all 9 panels: the U.S. is dark pink; Asian countries are in blue with India towards the center, Japan on the right, and China in the middle; and Europe is in the middle in shades of gray.

The vertical scope is the last 25 years, with the distant past at the top.

The top left panel shows GDP. The U.S. is a somewhat smaller fraction than it used to be. The big loser is Japan, and the big gainer is China — although China is not yet as important as Japan was 25 years ago.

The middle left shows population, which is always pretty stable. India and China have always been the most populous, but India is slowly taking the lead. Most Americans are surprised to find out that we’re the 3rd most populous country, and amongst developed countries we’re the ones with the consistently highest population growth rate (yeah Mormons!, yeah evangelical Christians, yeah immigration!).

The middle panel shows air traffic: a good indicator of development. Here, we see a shift towards Asia over the last generation. Directly to the right of that is shipping. There’s been a huge surge towards Asia here. Of course, this is export driven, but a lot of it is also the warm, temperate, western Pacific, and the ability to build brand new harbors to service container ships (which are a new thing over the last generation or two, and revolutionary at that).

The bottom row is reserved for the bad news.

The left panel shows refugees. Not surprisingly, Afghanistan, Iraq, and Somalia are the fat ones there, and Syria is the big new one at the bottom. Do note that the refugee problem in Afghanistan was at least as large before America got heavily involved there as it is now. And we’ve been out of Somalia for 25 years, and have avoided Syria. Also note that there are several refugee problems that have been solved, so it isn’t like these things are intractable.

The middle panel shows remittances: payments made to the home country from citizens working overseas. Asia is big here, and most of that is people working in the Middle East. Do note that remittances to Mexico actually peaked 10 years ago. Politicians have been leading from behind long before Obama made it trendy: they’re most worried about immigration, when economists will tell you that it’s a story that’s getting stale.

The last panel, at the bottom right, shows carbon dioxide emissions. If you’re worried about that sort of thing, there’s really no point in worrying about anything other than China right now.

This accompanied an article entitled “Global Economy Loses Steam”.

9 Out of 5 Again

More on declining stock markets around the world, and whether they may or may not be indicative of a recession. Do note that this sort of ambiguity is really useful to journalists because it gives them more to write about.

… Why pay attention to the financial indexes that, as the old joke goes, have predicted 9 out of the past 5 recessions? There are three possible reasons the market selloff could be cause for concern.

The first is that a recession is coming but has yet to show up in the data. The U.S. seems due: Its economic expansion is now the fourthlongest since World War II, and the stock market is a leading, albeit error-prone, recession indicator.

But hard economic data are not behaving as they would before a recession. …

Do keep in mind that recessions do not die of old age. This is one of those ideas that people keep trotting out and that macroeconomists are really tired of explaining just isn’t there in the data.

What about the rest of the world?

…

Surveys of purchasing managers from around the world compiled by J.P. Morgan Chase and Markit show that overall economic activity slowed a bit in December but to a level consistent with normal, long-term trend growth.

So, China’s not doing great, Brazil is in the dumps, but everyone else is muddling through OK.

The third and most plausible possibility is that markets are losing confidence in policy makers, driven in particular by events in China and the U.S.

…

“We collectively lost faith in ability of the Chinese authorities to always do the right thing,” says Angel Ubide, a former hedge-fund manager now at the Peterson Institute for InternationalEconomics. By contrast, the Federal Reserve is transparent and independent. The problem is markets disagree with its plans.

This is not a big factor for macroeconomists. We know that policymakers can influence economies, but that influence isn’t very big to begin with.

Read the whole thing. In the print version of the January 21 issue of The Wall Street Journal it’s entitled “The Selloff May Not Mean a Recession”.

Tuesday, January 19, 2016

Keynes Investment Returns (Not Required)

There’s an old joke that the difference between an economics major and a finance major is that the finance major still thinks they can beat the market.

Keynes was well-known in his time as a successful investor (do not make the casual mistake being dismissive of Keynes, whether you like his conclusions or not, he’s one of those people that forgot more than the rest of us will ever know).

Anyway, there’s some (cute) recent research that even Keynes didn’t beat the market much. If you’re interested, here’s a short and non-technical discussion from the January 12 issue of The New York Times entitled “Keynes: Great Economist, Mediocre Currency Trader”, a little longer but technically accessible piece at Vox entitled “The returns to currency speculation: Evidence from Keynes the trader”.

State of the Union: The Data

How is the U.S. economy doing right now? Data helps. But keep in mind that journalists may not understand the data that well, and then if there’s a graphic sometimes it will get corrupted by artistic concerns. After principles, you are at the point where you should start picking up problems with data that’s presented to you. Check out this graphic:

16-01-12, WSJ Capture on the US Economy

This data was reported to summarize the performance of recent presidents in their 8th year. Except that it forgets about Bush I everywhere except the bottom panel – which shows approval rating rather than economic data. You’ll have trouble getting the economics right if you can’t consistently include all the presidents.

Also, keep in mind that presidents probably don’t do much to influence the economy. So it’s a good way to group year’s together … but don’t read too much into it.

Let’s start at the top left. Presidents are probably not responsible for the recessions that happen to occur when they’re in office. This makes Clinton look better than he was (the economy has almost 2 years to get going after the recession before he came into office). And Bush II inherited a recession, before he got hit with a second one, and that probably makes him look worse than he was. Slope over the majority of that graph is probably the best way to compare them. On that count, Clinton and Reagan look better than either Obama or Bush II. By the way, most of that memory of Reagan being so great is that steeper portion in the middle of his tenure.

Now go to the top right. This shows stock market indices. One of the things you should learn in this class is that you probably shouldn’t look at this at all for any macroeconomic insight: too many false positives and false negatives. And that goes both ways: using the stock market to predict the economy, or the economy to predict the stock market.

Now go to the middle left. You’ll note that consumer confidence roughly tracks the employment data directly above it. So there’s not much new here.

Digression: macroeconomists are not sure what to make of consumer confidence. It’s human nature to want to explain recessions with one or a few variables, but instead it seems to require a big list. Consumer confidence is on that list. But the only recession where it seems to have been the primary factor was the one in 1991-2. And that’s not shown in the chart!

Lastly, go to the middle panel on the right, which shows gas prices. This is an easy one: it doesn’t say adjusted for inflation, so these are nominal prices of gas, not the real price. So this is close to useless. Of course, gas costs more under Obama and Bush — the dollars used to pay for it aren’t worth as much.

All in all, it’s kind of sad (because some journalist probably worked hard on this), but a good student should recognize that … there isn’t much here. Democrats will not be happy to see that Obama doesn’t look much better than Bush II. And Republicans will not be happy to see that Clinton outdid Bush II, and was more than comparable to Reagan. I think both of those assessments are accurate, but there’s a lot of other data that could have supported that position.

This chart accompanied an article called “Obama to Note Work Yet to Be Done” that appeared in the January 12 issue of The Wall Street Journal (in preparation for his last State of the Union address).

Friday, January 15, 2016

Is This a Peak?

Is the U.S. economy peaking? Maybe. Some people think it is.

I am a bad person to ask on this one. Yes, this is my field of expertise. But personally, I tend to be too optimistic. So I tend to miss peaks as they’re happening.

One reason for this is that peaks and troughs are names that are poorly chosen. To me, peaks are sharp, and troughs are not.

But, in real time, peaks are hard for the public to feel, and troughs are more distinct. It’s like the tops of the business cycle are mountains, but old, rounded ones. And the business cycle lows points aren’t wide flat valleys between mountains, but the bottom of steep canyons.

Anyway, some people are wondering. Read “Behind the Pain: Misplaced Faith” in the January 14 issue of The Wall Street Journal.