Friday, April 10, 2020
What Tyler Cowen Thinks
On the internet, Tyler Cowen is the most famous/important economist. Here's what he said about social distancing, shutdowns, re-opening, and the pandemic. It sounds realistic to me.
Thursday, April 9, 2020
Putting COVID-19 Deaths In Context: A New Milestone
Part of the problem with COVID-19 is getting your mind around the scale of the numbers involved.
Yes, it's true, car accidents kill more Americans every year. So far. We're probably going to pass that in a couple of weeks (I haven't forecast that one yet).
Yes, it's also true that influenza kills more Americans every year. We're forecast to break that one as well. The thing is with the flu, it's not a single germ — it's a whole family of them. It also produces that death toll over months. The real comparison here will be the number of deaths next winter that are flu-related rather than SARS-CoV-2 related.
I remarked a while back that COVID-19 would overtake 9/11 in deaths. That seems like a long time ago, but it was less than 2 weeks ago that I made that prediction.
As I write this on the evening of April 9th, the total number of U.S. deaths is 16,679. A month ago, on the 9th of March, we'd had 26.
That's more in this one month that ... the entire Afghanistan war, Iraq wars, and fight against ISIS combined. It's actually already more than twice that amount. BTW: that's all conflict related deaths, not just the combat ones.
We're actually closing in the Korean War. We're forecast to pass the Vietnam War as well.
Anyway, I'm not trying to be morbid. I'm trying to come up with a number that puts this month in perspective with some other month. And I think I've finally found it. We've had more deaths in the past month than the U.S. Army (and Air Corps)† had in combat deaths in June 1944 — the month of the D-Day invasion. In fact, we've now passed every single month of World War II, including July 1944 (German counterattacks in Normandy), December 1944 (the Battle of the Bulge), February 1945 (Iwo Jima), and April 1945 (Okinawa).
† I was unable to find month by month death totals for Naval (and Marine) in World War II. They are kept track of by campaign, but every single one of those is already dwarfed by one month of COVID-19.
Yes, it's true, car accidents kill more Americans every year. So far. We're probably going to pass that in a couple of weeks (I haven't forecast that one yet).
Yes, it's also true that influenza kills more Americans every year. We're forecast to break that one as well. The thing is with the flu, it's not a single germ — it's a whole family of them. It also produces that death toll over months. The real comparison here will be the number of deaths next winter that are flu-related rather than SARS-CoV-2 related.
I remarked a while back that COVID-19 would overtake 9/11 in deaths. That seems like a long time ago, but it was less than 2 weeks ago that I made that prediction.
As I write this on the evening of April 9th, the total number of U.S. deaths is 16,679. A month ago, on the 9th of March, we'd had 26.
That's more in this one month that ... the entire Afghanistan war, Iraq wars, and fight against ISIS combined. It's actually already more than twice that amount. BTW: that's all conflict related deaths, not just the combat ones.
We're actually closing in the Korean War. We're forecast to pass the Vietnam War as well.
Anyway, I'm not trying to be morbid. I'm trying to come up with a number that puts this month in perspective with some other month. And I think I've finally found it. We've had more deaths in the past month than the U.S. Army (and Air Corps)† had in combat deaths in June 1944 — the month of the D-Day invasion. In fact, we've now passed every single month of World War II, including July 1944 (German counterattacks in Normandy), December 1944 (the Battle of the Bulge), February 1945 (Iwo Jima), and April 1945 (Okinawa).
† I was unable to find month by month death totals for Naval (and Marine) in World War II. They are kept track of by campaign, but every single one of those is already dwarfed by one month of COVID-19.
Some New COVID-19 Visualizations
TL sent this in. Beware. I found it took some time to load the images. I have not seen the "wave-breaking" graphs in any context before.
COVID-19 # 49 (Required Parts Are Highlighted)
Google has banned employees from using Zoom, due to security risks. The NYC schools have banned it too, and shifted to Microsoft's Teams. And here's a computer security professor from Princeton: "Let's make this simple: Zoom is malware.". And now 27 (at last count) state's Attorney's General are investigating. I definitely do not want to discourage the whole social distancing approach, but education administrators have once again been caught flat-footed in their belief that online education solves problems.
Boris Johnson spent a third night in the ICU, but was checked out to a regular hospital bed this morning.
Something to keep in mind when looking at the numbers:
New York City has started doing trench burials. They are a little more civilized than what was spotted on satellite images from Iran last month.
Anecdotally, people are saying online that the sounds of sirens in the streets of New York are not confirming a plateau of decline in cases.
The topic du jour in policy discussions is that SARS-CoV-2 appears to be hitting African-Americans harder. This is exactly the same issue that I raised with you in this post about whether they young get off easy. This could all be Simpson's Paradox. I am not saying with certainty that people are noting something that is unimportant. But I am noting that when you take multivariate cross-sectional data (like SARS-CoV-2 susceptibility) and attempt to explain it with a single variable, you are asking for inappropriate inferences.
Just for curiosity: the Wimbledon tennis tournament had an insurance policy that covered cancellation due to pandemics. It paid.
FWIW: Lloyds of London is famous for insuring just about anything, so I wonder if they did this policy. But Lloyds of London is not actually an insurance company, so those of you in finance might be interested in reading up on how it works.
Boris Johnson spent a third night in the ICU, but was checked out to a regular hospital bed this morning.
Something to keep in mind when looking at the numbers:
Remember the videos from China 10 weeks ago that we weren't sure were real? There are videos coming out of Russia of people running away from chasers wearing hazmat suits.Questions to ask: why haven’t we heard anything from those tens of thousands “cured” #CCPVirus patients in China? They don’t talk to their friends on social media? They don’t know how to use WeChat? They don’t even know how to use internet at all? https://t.co/OkZiIOWht9— Jennifer Zeng 曾錚 (@jenniferatntd) April 9, 2020
New York City has started doing trench burials. They are a little more civilized than what was spotted on satellite images from Iran last month.
Anecdotally, people are saying online that the sounds of sirens in the streets of New York are not confirming a plateau of decline in cases.
The topic du jour in policy discussions is that SARS-CoV-2 appears to be hitting African-Americans harder. This is exactly the same issue that I raised with you in this post about whether they young get off easy. This could all be Simpson's Paradox. I am not saying with certainty that people are noting something that is unimportant. But I am noting that when you take multivariate cross-sectional data (like SARS-CoV-2 susceptibility) and attempt to explain it with a single variable, you are asking for inappropriate inferences.
Just for curiosity: the Wimbledon tennis tournament had an insurance policy that covered cancellation due to pandemics. It paid.
FWIW: Lloyds of London is famous for insuring just about anything, so I wonder if they did this policy. But Lloyds of London is not actually an insurance company, so those of you in finance might be interested in reading up on how it works.
Tuesday, April 7, 2020
What I Wrote for This Class in 2003 (Required Parts Are Highlighted)
I've been asking students in my advanced macro class to submit questions for a quodlibet for almost 20 years.
In 2003, the original SARS outbreak was in the news.
Here's what one student asked,† and what I answered.
A lot of what I knew about pandemics in early January came from thinking about this epidemic and discussing it in that class. We don't know yet whether COVID-19 is the worst case scenario, but it's certainly a worse case. And we're still hoping for a vaccine or a fizzle out.‡
I'm a little amazed at that ballpark estimate. Lee and McKibben [2004], which I sited this year in this post, later estimated the costs at $45B in Hong Kong and China combined. Also interesting that I wrote that this epidemic (which petered out by June) was probably more important than the war in Iraq. In a way, we can now see that it was.
Up until Fall 2014, that quote used to reside on my SUU webpage. Then the suits decided it would be a good idea to make it harder for professors to make scholarly use of the SUU website. It was buried down a few levels, but just sitting there if anyone searched for it.
† I remember this student well. Gotta' figure she'd be almost 40 now. Hope she's healthy and staying safe. And believe it or not, Jake Miller was in that class too.
‡ BTW: they still have not developed a successful and safe vaccine for the initial SARS. They've been trying for 17 years.
In 2003, the original SARS outbreak was in the news.
Here's what one student asked,† and what I answered.
At the time this happened, we had zero experience with destructive epidemics. Ebola was like some urban myth we told about Africa. Anti-vaxxers were non-existent. China's economy was a tenth of its current size, and its politics seemed a lot cuddlier.How will the fear of exposure to the Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome (SARS) affect trade with other countries and the U.S. economy?
Gosh ... I wish I had an answer for this one. Let's think about this in terms of polar cases. The worst case scenario is that this is a contagious disease, for which we have no immunity, which has a 4% death rate. So, we're talking 250 million deaths worldwide. In the best case, a vaccine can be developed quickly with few side effects, and the whole scary situation fizzles out.
I think that its pretty obvious that people are worried about that worst case scenario. Expectations of that scenario could have enormous effects on the world economy without it ever even taking place. Already we are seeing drops in travel to East Asia, recommendations that people avoid travel to Toronto, Beijing, and Hong Kong, empty hotels, closed universities, hospitals and schools, and so on. How much damage is that doing - I don't know, I've heard no estimates. Here's a ballpark figure: big natural disasters in developed countries do $20-100B in damage. The U.S. can shake that off, but Hong Kong, and other small but wealthy countries would be devastated. This probably bears a lot more attention than the Iraq war. On the other hand, don't blow it out of proportion. Only a few thousand people have had SARS so far.
A lot of what I knew about pandemics in early January came from thinking about this epidemic and discussing it in that class. We don't know yet whether COVID-19 is the worst case scenario, but it's certainly a worse case. And we're still hoping for a vaccine or a fizzle out.‡
I'm a little amazed at that ballpark estimate. Lee and McKibben [2004], which I sited this year in this post, later estimated the costs at $45B in Hong Kong and China combined. Also interesting that I wrote that this epidemic (which petered out by June) was probably more important than the war in Iraq. In a way, we can now see that it was.
Up until Fall 2014, that quote used to reside on my SUU webpage. Then the suits decided it would be a good idea to make it harder for professors to make scholarly use of the SUU website. It was buried down a few levels, but just sitting there if anyone searched for it.
† I remember this student well. Gotta' figure she'd be almost 40 now. Hope she's healthy and staying safe. And believe it or not, Jake Miller was in that class too.
‡ BTW: they still have not developed a successful and safe vaccine for the initial SARS. They've been trying for 17 years.
John Prine RIP (Not Required)
I'm old enough to be in AARP now, but John Prine was well-know even before my time.
Over the years, I've heard his stuff, and it never did much for me. (Kind of surprising actually ... I like singer/songwriters and/or folk/rock generally, and in another lifetime I was a pretty mean finger-picker too).
Some of you know my wife Mary Jo. She's not a fan either, but she passed this one on to me this evening. Stephen Colbert and Prine recorded this in 2016 for the Late Show, but never aired it. The introduction is prophetic:
Anyway, he's been sick for over a week, and he passed away from SARS-CoV-2 on April 7th.
Over the years, I've heard his stuff, and it never did much for me. (Kind of surprising actually ... I like singer/songwriters and/or folk/rock generally, and in another lifetime I was a pretty mean finger-picker too).
Some of you know my wife Mary Jo. She's not a fan either, but she passed this one on to me this evening. Stephen Colbert and Prine recorded this in 2016 for the Late Show, but never aired it. The introduction is prophetic:
Anyway, he's been sick for over a week, and he passed away from SARS-CoV-2 on April 7th.
COVID-19 # 48 (Required Parts Highlighted)
The quarantine ended in Wuhan today. Reports are that the train stations were full, mostly with people leaving.
In the UK they are rolling out 5G phone services, just like here in the US. Those will help a lot with all of us trying to stay in touch through the internet. Except that there are internet rumors that the new cell towers are causing the disease so people are setting them on fire. You can't make stuff like this up.
Around the world, journalists are being arrested in increasing numbers for merely covering the pandemic in certain countries.
Iran has been making a stink about removing sanctions ever since the outbreak hit. But here's their official position:
They don't actually want help. They just want the sanctions removed.
Austria has announced plans to be the first European country to relax its quarantine measures. Starts next Tuesday with small shops being allowed to re-open with restrictions. A month ago, Austria was called a lot of bad names for closing their border with Italy.
Meanwhile, in the U.S., governors have roled out stay-at-home orders at different times:
I'm all for federalism, so I'd like to see who chose best. Having said that, whomever chose worse is going to have more deaths.
More evidence that deaths are undercounted:
And ... Quorum ... an operator of 24 hospitals (including the one in Tooele) is preparing a Chapter 11 filing. Don't panic: Chapter 11 does allow operations to remain open, it just puts up a barrier against creditors. The problem for a hospital though, is that vendors are unlikely to keep shipping them supplies.
South Korea has been the gold standard for testing, but now it's Switzerland (which is one of the worst hit countries in Europe).
Do note that this scaled per million people, so logging it is probably not a great idea. The U.S. is closing in on South Korea, which is not something you're likely to pick up from the TV.
Remember what I posted about time series charts not implying destiny? Here's the updated one for western Europe:
The Netherlands has figured out something that others have not. I more or less predicted something like this would happen: just because trending data has hung together in the past does not imply it will hang together in the future.
Finally, some actual news out of Iran.
Boris Johnson is reported to be receiving only supplemental oxygen in the ICU, and is not on a ventilator. He is breathing on his own. I'm speculating here, but low levels of oxygen are typically delivered through a canula. Higher levels require a hood or tent with a higher oxygen concentration inside.
The Health Minister in Israel, who publicly claimed that SARS-CoV-2 infections are related to moral failings, has tested positive.
China reported zero deaths today, for the first time since mid-January. Also, BBC reports that China's successes do not seem to be reported much by Chinese media. Their speculation matches up with a point I've made in class:
I'm keeping any eye on these countries over the next few weeks; India, Japan, Russia, and Turkey. I'm not liking what I'm hearing out of them.
On a personal note, our friend in Australia who was hospitalized, has been released.
In the UK they are rolling out 5G phone services, just like here in the US. Those will help a lot with all of us trying to stay in touch through the internet. Except that there are internet rumors that the new cell towers are causing the disease so people are setting them on fire. You can't make stuff like this up.
Around the world, journalists are being arrested in increasing numbers for merely covering the pandemic in certain countries.
Iran has been making a stink about removing sanctions ever since the outbreak hit. But here's their official position:
#Iran's FM spox:— Heshmat Alavi (@HeshmatAlavi) April 6, 2020
"We have not & will not make a request from the U.S. to send aid to the Islamic Republic of Iran. It is not our policy to request aid from leaders of the American regime."
U.S. sanctions are not impeding Iran's #coronavirus fight.
The regime is the problem. pic.twitter.com/0N3ZZJQSif
They don't actually want help. They just want the sanctions removed.
Austria has announced plans to be the first European country to relax its quarantine measures. Starts next Tuesday with small shops being allowed to re-open with restrictions. A month ago, Austria was called a lot of bad names for closing their border with Italy.
Meanwhile, in the U.S., governors have roled out stay-at-home orders at different times:
I'm all for federalism, so I'd like to see who chose best. Having said that, whomever chose worse is going to have more deaths.
More evidence that deaths are undercounted:
This is similar to Wuhan 2 months ago, where the cremation business showed way more activity than was in the official numbers.It’s not just deaths in hospitals which are up. On an average day before this crisis there were 20-25 deaths at home in NYC. Now in the midst of this pandemic the number is 200-215. *Every day*. 5/— Mark D. Levine (@MarkLevineNYC) April 6, 2020
1/ @nycgov #Covid_19 dths supposedly ⬇️ 2day— Dr. Andrea Feigl (@andreafeigl1) April 6, 2020
I don't believe these #s ...
about half a million people in Iran are suffering from COVED-19, a member of the National Coronavirus Combat Taskforce has disclosed. Speaking to the Islamic Republic's official news agency, IRNA, on Monday, April 6, Hamid Souri asserted Why?
Yesterday's 630 toll reported just before 9pm; hourly, ~50 dths + in NYC the last few days; the 594 # reported in AM ... no increase since
My estimate: We underreported ~300 - 400 dths in NYC 2day
And ... Quorum ... an operator of 24 hospitals (including the one in Tooele) is preparing a Chapter 11 filing. Don't panic: Chapter 11 does allow operations to remain open, it just puts up a barrier against creditors. The problem for a hospital though, is that vendors are unlikely to keep shipping them supplies.
South Korea has been the gold standard for testing, but now it's Switzerland (which is one of the worst hit countries in Europe).
Do note that this scaled per million people, so logging it is probably not a great idea. The U.S. is closing in on South Korea, which is not something you're likely to pick up from the TV.
Remember what I posted about time series charts not implying destiny? Here's the updated one for western Europe:
The Netherlands has figured out something that others have not. I more or less predicted something like this would happen: just because trending data has hung together in the past does not imply it will hang together in the future.
Finally, some actual news out of Iran.
... About half a million people in Iran are suffering from COVED-19, a member of the National Coronavirus Combat Taskforce has disclosed. Speaking to the Islamic Republic's official news agency, IRNA, on Monday, April 6, Hamid Souri asserted...This is from Radio Farda. This would make the Iranian outbreak the worst one in the world. It is broadly consistent with the number of deaths kept track of by dissident group PMOI/MEK, which is now at 19,500, implying a fatality rate of 4%, which (while on the high side) had not been unheard of in other locations. Also, the U.S. is looking to block Iran's request for $5B in aid from the IMF: they are OK with goods and services aid going to Iran, but they don't want cash that can be put to other uses going there. Also, the Iranian military has cancelled a big parade in Tehran scheduled for later this month.
Boris Johnson is reported to be receiving only supplemental oxygen in the ICU, and is not on a ventilator. He is breathing on his own. I'm speculating here, but low levels of oxygen are typically delivered through a canula. Higher levels require a hood or tent with a higher oxygen concentration inside.
The Health Minister in Israel, who publicly claimed that SARS-CoV-2 infections are related to moral failings, has tested positive.
China reported zero deaths today, for the first time since mid-January. Also, BBC reports that China's successes do not seem to be reported much by Chinese media. Their speculation matches up with a point I've made in class:
China's government tends not to trust the numbers it announces, which are reported without caveat in the western press. Also, Xi Jinping has been spotted in public in Beijing twice this week ... both times wearing a mask. Videos from Guangzhou show the quarantine is still in place there.This either means #China's media outlets know all too well that there are flaws in the accounting here or, more likely, that the Party knows there are flaws in its accounting so it’s ordered a cautious presentation of zero #coronavirus deaths in its media. #covid19— Stephen McDonell (@StephenMcDonell) April 7, 2020
I'm keeping any eye on these countries over the next few weeks; India, Japan, Russia, and Turkey. I'm not liking what I'm hearing out of them.
On a personal note, our friend in Australia who was hospitalized, has been released.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)